web statistics

Posted: Sunday, 28 July 2019 22:47

If you Like this article, please click

Pisco Punch for Peru, Pisco is Sour for Chile... for Now

July 28: Pisco Punch and Pisco Sour are two of the most delicious cocktails that can be crafted out of this Latin American brandy-like spirit introduced by the Spanish settlers in the 16th century along with wine in Peru and Chile, but its increasing popularity and huge potential in India, predicted by delWine in 2003, has the two countries fighting over its GI registration in India, with Peru finally winning the GI tag last month and Chile bracing up to continue the fight in the High Court

On July 14, 2005 the World lntellectual Property Organization (WIPO) formally notified to the Government of Peru that the appellation of origin Pisco had been registered in favour of Peru in the International Registry for Appellations of Origin. Based on this registration, the Embassy of Peru had applied to the GI Registry office in India in September, 2005 for the grant of GI Status for Pisco.  It was granted a ‘Peruvian Pisco’ status and issued a certificate of registration on 19 March, 2010.

However, Peru was not satisfied with the ruling as they wanted the Pisco tag; a few countries have been making Pisco, notably Chile which has been making it for a long time. So they filed an appeal before the Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB). After hearing the case, it accepted the appeal and accordingly granted the right of Pisco to be registered in their favour last month on 17June, 2019. Chile has reportedly raised objection on this order and plans to approach the High Court through Associacion de Productores de Pisco, AG In Chile.

At the present time Costa Rica, Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, Venezuela, Panama, Cuba, Guatemala, Nicaragua and the Dominican Republic in South America and Thailand in Asia have already  recognized Pisco as exclusively for Peru. With the current order of 17, June, 2019 India has also granted them the same status.

Pisco Story and Delhi Wine Club

The story of Pisco began for Indian Wine Academy and Delhi Wine Club 16 years ago in 2003. At one of the Delhi Wine Club dinners with Chilean wines at La Cave Restaurant at Hotel Grand (then Grand Hyatt) Victor Muñoz, Deputy Chief of Mission of the Embassy of Peru in Delhi was also present. He was impressed enough to request Arora, President of the Club and Indian Wine Academy to meet with the Peruvian Ambassador, H. E. Mr. Benjamin Ruiz.

His words still ring in my ears, ‘you promote Chilean wines so much; how about showcasing Peruvian wines at one of your wine club dinners that we will host. Being a neutral wine promoter, I readily agreed. A couple of meetings with His Excellency for details and the stage was set for a memorable dinner hosted graciously by him at his residence on 15 December, 2003. At his request as the host I relented for Pisco and Pisco cocktails to be included in the List of wines served.

The evening was a grand success but the wines received only lukewarm response from members. But Pisco cocktails were on fire and the members loved them; I being a Vinotaler, politely abstained from tasting them.  My recommendation to the Ambassador was that India was not ready for Peruvian wines yet, what with the aggressive promotion of its neighbouring Chile exporting value- for money- wines getting ever so popular. I recommended him instead to promote Pisco as a cocktail ingredient. Unfortunately, they did not have budgets to promote it and the matte was dropped with me making a few feeble unsuccessful efforts to volunteer the promotion through associates.

Pisco is Peru

When I visited Madrid Fusion in 2007 I was impressed by the ‘Pisco is Peru’ stand which was serving Pisco cocktails out of a List of 6-8 items. Even then I remember approaching the Embassy to take a clue from the heavy rush there and look at promoting it in India. Later, I was very impressed with a Chilean Pisco promotion in Valencia in 2009 when I had gone to judge at Concours Mondial de Bruxelles. This was followed by a wine festival I attended in Delhi by ProChile where Pisco cocktails served as a welcome drink were extremely popular with the guests.  

Pisco in Peru

Pisco is a small city located in the Department of Ica in Peru and the capital of Pisco Province. Pisco was founded in 1640 and originally prospered because of its vineyards and became noted for its grape brandy christened as Pisco.  The town of Santa Maria Magdalena, founded in 1572, had a port named Pisco, after the name of the valley in which it was located. This port became an important route for distribution of the liqueur throughout Peru. Over time, the town of Santa Maria Magdalena became simply known as Pisco' with the same name adopted for the grape brandy produced from the area. In a few decades, Pisco was distributed along the entire coast of Peru and Chile, as well as the Pacific and Europe.

Relations between Peru and Chile have historically been some of the most troubled in South America, but the past few years have brought a new energy to the relationship. Peru's resentment toward Chile can be traced as far back as the War of the Pacific in the late 19th century, when Chile defeated both Bolivia and Peru. As a result, Peru lost part of its territory.

For some of the related Articles, please visit:

Peruvian Wines And PISCO Tasting 

Fascinating Chile Wine n Food Evening

Peruvian Gastronomic Festival with French wines

DelWine has in its possession all the 26 documents detailing the Peruvian expensive and long journey from 2005 to June 2019, giving them the victory over the neighbouring Chile. For the moment Pisco is sour for the Chileans. It is interesting that the documents submitted in 2005 by the Embassy of Peru list H.E. Ruiz and Victor Muñoz as representing Peru, making one believe that perhaps the Delhi Wine Club dinner followed by my recommendations catalysed them into see the future and opt for Registration of GI. With the Indian market ready to accept exotic alcoholic products from throughout the world, it seems quite likely.

In any case, Peruvians Pisco has the Punch while Chile might feel the taste of Pisco sour ... at least for now. Ms. Chanchal Purohit, a trade mark and patent attorney and a consultant to delWine says,' this is a very unusual case where Chile has been opposing equally strongly, as they have also been producing Pisco apparently for a very long time. No wonder it took 14 years to get the Registration/appeal process so far. Chile will undoubtedly file an appeal which can be filed within 90 days after they are given all documents in the case. Only the High Court will then decide, which one or if both can be allowed to use the Pisco GI label in India.'

Subhash Arora

If you Like this article please click on the Like button   

 Comments:

 
 

William P. Cook Says:

 

Thank you Subhash, I enjoyed your play on words. I understand the confusion, but alas, our good friends from Spain have led you astray I am afraid.. Pisco Punch was actually an invention of a bar in San Francisco in the late 1800’s called the Bank Exchange Saloon and was invented by an American named Duncan Nicol. Pisco itself, was introduced to America when it was brought up from Pisco, Peru to California during the Gold Rush by traders who sailed along the Pacific Coast of the Americas. Debates about names and origins are all in good fun, but for us in Peru, the Pisco Sour is 100% Peruvian I am afraid lol!!! Everyone in the Club is most welcome, however, to visit us in Peru and enjoy not only our wonderful Pisco Sours, but other Pisco libations, including the Chilcana (a mixture of Pisco Quebranta, fresh lemon juice and ginger ale), perhaps a name we in Peru have expropriated from our dear neighbors to the South lol!!! Look forward to seeing you in Delhi soon and to enjoying some fine wine together. Best regards, Bill

Posted @ August 06, 2019 11:05

 

Subhash Arora Says:

 

Dear William,

Since I am not married to a Peruvian or a Chilean, I have to take a neutral stand. I used Pisco Punch and Pisco Sour in the heading to stress Peru had hit a Punch and Chile felt things were sour. I do know Pisco Punch is a cocktail in Peru anyway-‘cos I had noticed it being served in ‘Peru is Pisco’ stand in Spain. Pisco Sour is of course the whiskey sour of Latin America I am told and have seen it served by both the countries on several occasions. The matter is still subjudice. I am sure Chileans are going to the High Court. The Long History in both the countries of making Pisco will decide the fate by the judge. I wrote the Article merely as a journalist with the hope to promote the drink in India per se- free from any bias or comment. Let us see which way the High Court goes. Best of Luck. Subhash Arora

Posted @ August 03, 2019 13:10

 

William P. Cook Says:

 

My dear friends you could not be more incorrect when it comes to the proper terminology of how Pisco is consumed and where. The Pisco Sour is the national beverage of Peru not Chile, and no one in my beloved second home of Peru ever refers to our delicious libation as a Pisco Punch!!! With all due respect to our Chilean neighbors, they may use Pisco Punch but for us Peruvians (even if just by marriage), we only drink Pisco Sours (which is also the name of my beloved boat). Best regards, Bill

Posted @ August 02, 2019 16:30

 
       
Share

Want to Comment ?
 
   
Please enter your comments in the space provided below. If there is a problem, please write directly to arora@delwine.com. Thank you.
 

Captcha
Generate a new image

Type letters from the image:


Please note that it may take some time to get your comment published...Editor

Archives

Skip Navigation Links
Indian Wine Day
From Archives
Wine Retail
Wine Tourism
Wine India Moves
Book Review
Launch
Winery
TechTalk
Photo Gallery
Readers' Comments
Editorial
Media
Video Wall
Media Partners
Ask Wineguyindia
Wine & Food
Wine Guru
Perspectives
Gerry Dawes
Harvest Reports
Mumbai Reports
India Wine Awards 2019 Results
Upcoming Events
  Upcoming Events    
On Facebook On Twitter   Youtube RSS
 

INDIAN WINE ACADEMY

Private consultancy devoted to promotion of wine culture in India through various programmes including wine appreciation evenings, short term courses, wine trade shows, organising visits of foreign wine producers, helping in location of distributors, offering information on the market and the importers and Indian producers. Publishers of delWine -

More

Our Location

Contact Us

Correspondence Address
247, First Floor Sant Nagar,
East of Kailash,
New Delhi -110065
Phone- +91-11- 41622892
Email
arora@indianwineacademy.com